The Rolling Thunder Revue
Bob Dylan‘s 1976 musical caravan, The Rolling Thunder Revue, is being commemorated with the release of a 39-CD collection of almost 400 tracks: The Rolling Thunder Revue: The 1976 Live Recordings. However, calling the Rolling Thunder Revue a concert tour comes nowhere near capturing the scale, or the enormity, of the event Dylan and company had created.
Crisscrossing Canada and the United States, Dylan and his ever-changing and evolving cast of characters performed in both typical and atypical venues. From arena shows to community halls on Native American reservations, they brought their carnival of sounds to anyone who would listen.
While the core lineup featured luminaries like Roger McGuinn and Mick Robson (lead guitar), Rob Stoner (bass), and Scarlett Rivera (violin), it would swell and contract like the tide of the ocean on a regular basis. At any given time it could include Joan Baez, Kinky Friedman, Bob Neuwirth, and countless others.
The mid-1970s had seen Dylan release the critically and commercially acclaimed albums Blood on the Tracks and Desire. So it could be said he was riding high on the backs of their success. He could have been packing venues on a traditional tour, no problem. However, Dylan was never one for conventions, and the Rolling Thunder Revue was never going to fit anyone’s description of a typical tour.
In scope and desire it was much like Dylan himself. Over-reaching and striving to be something beyond the norm, it would occasionally go off the rails and descend into chaos. But at its core both the man and the tour were brilliant torrents of musical and creative energy. The Rolling Thunder Revue was a celebration of the music and the man, and a big step in the development of the myth of Bob Dylan.
Sites and Sounds
As befitted the raucous nature of the tour, the 39-CD set is not your average live recording. Instead of a record of one night on a tour preserved like an insect in amber, carefully edited and curated, we are treated to something a little more anarchic. Tracks are plucked from locations around the U.S. and Canada in an ever-shifting kaleidoscope of people and places. Like the ever-changing collection of performers, each site becomes as much a part of the experience as the music.
Sometimes the audience noise is much what you’d expect from any live recording, but other times the sounds wafting up onto the stage during the show bring a different atmosphere to life. Dylan was trying to escape the walls of the concert experience by bringing the Rolling Thunder Revue to places people like him didn’t normally play – places like small town halls – and you begin to hear and feel the difference as you listen to song after song on this collection.
On occasion you’ll hear the same four or five songs over and over again as the tour ambles from one location to another. While that might not sound like it would make for a great listening experience, it allows you to appreciate the nuances of each song. How the band might change things up a little each night in order to keep the song fresh – or conversely how they’re able to play a tune the same way night after night without it beginning to sound stale.
On the Road
This collection gives you a deeper insight into what it would mean for a musician to go on such an extended tour. Playing the same set night after night with little or no variation in anything, including the between-song patter. Sometimes you find yourself wondering if the disc has skipped backwards as you hear Dylan introducing Joan Baez in the same way for the same song three times.
It can be disconcerting, but it is also something of a revelation. These people are doing their best to make each performance something special for audiences all over and you start to appreciate the enormity of that task with each disc you play and song you hear.
Not once on the 39 discs does a performance sound mailed in. Dylan and his accomplices gave it their all night after night no matter where they were or who they were performing for. The tour was an unprecedented event, and these recordings capture some of the energy and spirit of what went into to making it so magnificent.
Rough-and-tumble
In this age of digital recordings and auto-tuning we are used to perfection in our audio. The Rolling Thunder Revue was from another era. The sound quality is iffy in places, with microphones cutting out and voices catching as a note is missed. But that’s live music, and what is captured here is a record of an event – a piece of musical and cultural history that will never come again.
The Rolling Thunder Revue releases – commemorating the 50th anniversary of the tour – capture an experience and remind us of a time when music was raw, real and intimate even in a big concert setting. I saw Dylan in 1979, and it was a comparatively tame event in a hockey arena. A great show, but produced and carefully curated, with none of the anarchy and celebratory nature that made the Rolling Thunder Revue such a unique experience.
The box set of this epic tour is the closest we’re going to come to being able to capture that experience for posterity. Spend a few days or weeks immersing yourself in the music and the time – you won’t regret it.
Blogcritics The critical lens on today's culture & entertainment