‘We’ll See‘
We’ll See is the newest play about the Apple family by writer and director Richard Nelson. The intimate drama unfolds in real time on the eve of the midterms, November 3, 2026. This world premiere is the latest installment of the Apple Family plays, now a series of 13. They’re part of Nelson’s Rhinebeck Panorama, a cycle of plays written over the last 16 years embracing three families who live in the historic Hudson Valley town of Rhinebeck, New York. This latest work, like the other plays, is a Public Theater presentation. It runs until November 29, 2026.
What does one do while waiting for the results of perhaps the most crucial election for civil rights in a constitutionally democratic nation, one where citizens are marching in “No Kings” protests against a would-be fascist authoritarian in the White House?
Barbara (Maryann Plunkett), the eldest Apple sibling, hosts a dinner with Marian (Laila Robins) who lives with her. The dinner includes Jane (Sally Murphy) and brother Richard (Jay O. Sanders) who leaves to pick up his actress girlfriend Yvonne Winters (Yvonne Woods). Barbara, a 74-year-old English teacher who is being encouraged to retire by the principal, a former student who doesn’t align with her, leads the conversation. She also gives the opening and closing statements of the play, recites poems that relate to the play’s themes, and discusses various incidents in her classes with students.
The Apple family dinner reunion
On this night the family has reunited to affirm the principles of democratic decency and equality. They’ve chosen unity and each other’s company for uplifting conversation and conviviality – but with a few caveats. First, they agree not to discuss politics or rail against the voluminous list of traitorous constitutional violations. Second, the Apples will not honor any of those in power by name, especially “him.” Third, they will rally around inspirational topics. They will discuss their own lives and feelings about their current, personal situations. Finally, they will not look at their phones or turn on the radio or TV to check the election results.
During the first 15 minutes of the play, in a conversation about a migrant celebration of Thanksgiving, sisters Barbara and Marian sing a historic song (“Emigrant’s Lament”) once sung by the Hutchinson family singers. Throughout We’ll See we note the nuanced themes which Nelson understatedly works in.
The state of the nation
In fact the “given” for the Apple family gathering on this night is that they see their lives and the lives of citizens and migrants alike in imminent danger from the current government. They oppose actions that “he” and his party have traitorously undertaken in a rejection of traditional American democratic ideals laid out in the Declaration of Independence and Constitution. For them “he” is a clear and present danger.
Interestingly, Nelson also makes their views manifest through pauses and what they agree not to talk about.
We come to understand their profound sorrow about what “he” has done to the United States and what citizens like themselves have allowed “him” to do inadvertently. Because citizens have not effectively stopped or removed him for all time, that has placed themselves in their own personal, moral conflagration.
Goodness
After all, evil flourishes when “good” people do nothing. Therefore, if they presume to “see” themselves as good, then what are they? Who are they for allowing hateful criminals to lead the country, kidnap migrants off the streets to fulfill ICE agents’ quotas, and fill up bank accounts of detention centers’ owners? Barbara in particular refers to an incident that occurred in a local park. Of course the Thanksgiving celebration for her ESL students must be quietly held, without publicity, because migrants will be there.
As they talk and set up for dinner, the Apples’ familiar camaraderie creates an intimate, slowly paced, relaxed atmosphere. They share personal stories, tell silly jokes, tease one another, make wisecracks and compliments about one another, relate interesting philosophical anecdotes, discuss Rhinebeck history, and much more. Yvonne discusses the healing aspect of theater, relating a pointed incident with an autistic child.
Jane Apple
Every now and then they discuss family members not present, i.e. how Tim, Jane’s husband, changed his voting site (from Rhinebeck to Brooklyn where they also live). ane brings up her dislike of Rhinebeck’s change of voting site from the wonderful, historic Town Hall to a retirement facility, a point that strikes a nerve because she and Richard are working on a project about the town’s history.
Her dislike of that change segues to her real dislike, the Democrats, for not caring to change things that relate to her life. She feels their complicity with the majority party. And at some point she finally admits she didn’t vote. With understanding, Barbara chides her: perhaps if she had voted she would feel less depressed, more hopeful.
Salient questions
Some of the siblings, for example the youngest, Jane, in quieter moments ask questions about their own and by extension their family’s American identity. Marian asks what “he” has made them become.
Listening to this group of artists, teachers and lawyers one feels a part of it, encouraged by the atmospheric dinner (the food is real), the incredible ensemble work, the direction, and the creative team supporting Nelson’s vision. Jason Ardizzone-West’s minimal and domestic set and Susan Hilferty’s homely costume design complete the portrait of a family that represents thinking citizens. Though we may not have such a family, we long for their community and empathize with it.
Seeing the play after the midterm results, Barbara’s parting words, “We’ll see,” directed to three audience members (the audience is on three sides in the Barbaralee theater), are an ongoing meme for the country’s uncertain future.
We’ll See is at the Public Theatre, extended through November 29, 2026.
Blogcritics The critical lens on today's culture & entertainment