With most plays, I can start writing my review – at least in my head – as soon as the lights come up. Old or new, good or not-so-good, the material and production make intelligible impressions. But now and then I see a play that takes longer to wrap my brain around. If that’s what Daphne Silbiger was going for with her new play Very Blue Light, it worked. The show thoughtfully and skillfully plumbs the psyches of a generation that’s come to maturity in a time of unprecedented polycrisis.
The philosophies at play here go well beyond traditional liberalism, MAGA, and socialism. Coleman (an incandescent Sam Im) arrives in the desert community of Marfa, Texas to visit his old school chums Angela (a warmly sympathetic performance by Ellenor Riley-Condit) and Magna, formerly Mike (a gutsy and heart-wrenching turn by Dom Martello). These desert denizens seem to be scraping by via the gig economy.
(And perhaps in Angela’s case some independent means? I have to admit that some bits of the early dialogue escaped me; I adjusted, but at first it seemed the cast was speaking Silbiger’s witty words a generation too fast for me!)
Their friend Michigan (Anita Parrott) is a highly politicized part-time hacker and passionate philosopher who also seems to exist on the margins of the economy, mixing legit work with dubious extracurriculars.
Coleman, on the other hand, works for Tesla, where end-times talk is common: “Work is super nervous about infrastructure stuff.” He believes LLMs and AI “slop generators” are conditioning people into “passive neolib drones who just want to consume consume consume.” On a personal level, he struggles to grok Magna’s transition. And deep down he’s interested in a carnal encounter with Angela – who notes amusingly that straight sex, in the new social ecosystem, has become somewhat “controversial.”
There’s a Sam Shepard-esque out-of-time feel to the action despite continual references to current sociopolitical realities. This almost sci-fi aura becomes explicit late in the play. But even before that, the characters seem lost in an extra-dimensional space.
Some are pining for a sign that they are or aren’t doing the right things for themselves. Michigan, despite a deepening friendship with Magna, thinks of a move to Los Angeles. Coleman, despite his tech career, flirts with a kind of rootless road warrior identity and finds relief in hanging out with people who aren’t work colleagues. Magna lives in a bardo between social acceptance and rejection, threats of harassment and violence at the edges. And Angela plans a move to Alaska while worrying that some of her evolving viewpoints are turning her into a right-winger.

Warm realism dominates most of the dialogue, although at one point an intellectualized dispute between Michigan and Coleman calls to mind Thomas Mann’s The Magic Mountain – another story set in an out-of-time limbo. Michigan takes exception to Coleman’s opinions and lashes out: “MAGA’s a cult – a huge distraction, and perversely so,” yet the Left’s preoccupation with socialism and the like “are holding less and less water, because they don’t have shit to say about what’s actually going on!”
Silbiger’s firm grip on her people and their social milieu, combined with the exceptional cast guided by director Emily Moler, form characters of recognizable complexity. It becomes easy to feel – indeed seems impossible not to feel – for each one of them, for their predicaments, for their feelings that they’re drifting towards something in ways they probably can’t control.
Mysticism and politics; the acutely personal and the abstractions of philosophy; mixing these in one story and by doing so engaging minds and hearts alike is a rare talent. Very Blue Light exemplifies it. See it at The Tank through October 4, 2026.
Blogcritics The critical lens on today's culture & entertainment