Molière’s The Imaginary Invalid
If a merry heart brings healing, The Imaginary Invalid by Molière, in this version adapted by Bill Irwin from a translation by Doug Skinner, is what you need. The French farce, with its influence from commedia dell’arte, premiered in 1673. A sick Molière played the hypochondriac Argan, finished the fourth performance giving it everything he had, then collapsed and died at home hours later. With that ironic send-off, the play has lasted for over 350 years.
This cleverly wrought production directed by Brandon J. Dirden is at the Todd Haimes Theater until November 22, 2026. It is a treat to see this classic handled with precision by cast and creatives who obviously appreciate its satiric whimsy and trenchant current themes.
Bill Irwin
Bill Irwin, the clown prince of theater, brings his background at Ringling Brothers to his performances (pacing, mime and rhythm). He leads a fine ensemble and delivers superbly in the role of the wealthy Argan, who spends a fortune on his persuasive doctor’s regimens. Wisely, he balances authenticity with innate comic timing. With his high-stakes investment in the character’s belief that his doctors are keeping him alive, Irwin lays out the field upon which the ensemble zanily frolics.
With a nod to commedia dell’arte and the Comédie-Française, a pantomime summarizes the action and dresses the stage with Beowulf Boritt’s ingenious, period, scenic design. The masked, robed Pantolone gets the audience’s attention by striking a long staff on the stage floor. Then he strikes the traditional trois coups which summons the actors to begin. Quickly, the actors’ movements, directed by Lorenzo Pisoni, whisk the mesmerized audience from the digital age to the 17th century.
The pantomime
Masked, robed doctors pull red ribbons from Pantalone’s robe, symbolizing the bleeding treatment practiced at the time. With the ribbons they pull into place the walls and the ceiling, and add the simple pieces of furniture to create the set: the home of Argan. Through the hustle, Irwin invisibly takes his position center stage in a modern-ish recliner. The robed, masked actors crowd around and dress him, then swivel him around. Lo and behold, Irwin has transformed into the iconic hypochondriac!
Spinning its magic, the play explodes with satire and farce into a morality tale about obsessions with quack doctors, true and false love, and a brilliant servant who saves the day, all in the 90-minute twinkling of an eye.
The play’s economy creates maximum laughs
Economy for maximum laughs is a watchword for this production. The modern dialogue serves as a counterpoint to the situation, which Irwin’s adaptation smartly leaves in the 17th century. However, to streamline the play, Irwin removes the customary “interludes” that lengthen Molière’s work.
Essentially, Irwin keeps the structure and conflict that drive the momentum. For example, it was customary at the time for wealthy families to arrange marriages. Argan does this with a satiric twist. The marriage he proposes is not an economic arrangement. Instead, it erupts from Argan’s desire to indulge his hypochondria and always have a doctor or three at the ready. Dr. Diafoirus and son Thomas (Hiram Delgado) are the brother and nephew of Dr. Purgon, Argan’s primary physician. If his daughter Angelique (the lovely Ava Lalezarzadeh) marries Thomas, Argan will have 24/7 access to all three doctors.
Funny scenes of real and fake romance
In the scene when Thomas first meets Angelique, we learn in coded language that he can hardly wait to have children and is practicing by himself, alone. The reference to masturbation lands. Thomas appears as the 17th-century equivalent of a 21st-century dweeb.
Though Argan’s word is law, the lovely Angelique loves Cléante (Daniel Croix Henderson). With Toinette’s help and understanding, the couple hope to pledge themselves to each other.

Wisely, Irwin includes the singing scene between Angelique and her love Cléante. Humorously, they sing in codes to each other in front of Argan and the others. The fun turns into laughs as Argan ends up foolishly ridiculing himself. The suspense builds as the complications heighten when Argan’s wife Beline (Crystal A.Dickinson) insists Angelique go to a nunnery. Who will help Angelique marry the man of her dreams and not the slow-witted Thomas?
Brooks Ashmanskas
Brooks Ashmanskas portrays both brother doctors, refining the ‘”likeness” of each. However, despite differences in curly period wigs (Nikiya Mathis), variations in speech, demeanor, and costuming (the excellent Karen Perry), we note they are one in the same and recognize the same pompousness and presumptuousness of erudition. Casting the fine, comic actor in both roles gives the audience more time to appreciate the sendup of greedy doctors.
This casting also reveals how their incompetence and unscrupulous tactics run in the family. Indeed, Delgado’s Thomas stokes laughter when he explains his approach as like the “ancients” and against the discovery method. The family prefers to “practice” not at court where they would be held accountable. Indeed, the king and courtiers expect cures. Thus, “cash cows” like Argan, as Toinette (Rachel Bloom) counsels, reap easy money.
Argan enjoys his charlatan doctors
When the doctors overcharge for simple treatments like enemas and bleeding, Argan’s brother Beralde (the excellent Dylan Baker) wonders that Argan lives after all their abuse. But Argan is enamored of being ill. He enjoys the sympathy it brings from his second wife, the gold-digger Beline. She plots with Bonnefoy to disinherit Angelique and extract as much cash as possible while Argan lives. Then, she plans to inherit all of his fortune after he dies. Will the conniving Beline win?
Three themes stand out. First, gold-diggers marry sick men to easily inherit. Second, doctors overcharge for treatments that don’t work. Third, the course of true love never runs smoothly. These unspool with histrionics, hilarity and currency.
Additionally, Molière’s theme that education can be meaningless unless put to effective use threads throughout. Clearly, Beralde’s dictum to “rest” makes sense. Also, clever observers like Toinette and Beralde provide the wisdom to expose the difference between the frauds and the truthtellers. Thus, to distinguish fact from fiction, we must watch what “they” do, not what they say. In that The Imaginary Invalid rings most true for us today.
The Imaginary Invalid is at the Todd Haimes Theater through November 22, 2026.
Blogcritics The critical lens on today's culture & entertainment