To accept this fever dream of a show, you have to be willing to surrender yourself to it. Whether or not you’ve read Jean Cocteau’s 1929 novella Les Enfants Terribles, knowing something of the story ahead of time will help you make sense of Michael Gardner’s new adaptation.
But will that knowledge smooth your path into the claustrophobic world this inflamed production creates in the tiny East Village Basement space on East 9th Street? You will have to see for yourself.
A Terrible Two
You’ll witness the twisted relationship between Elizabeth (Maysie Jane Kilgore) and her younger brother Paul (Rutger Scott) via their extravagant playacting and a lot of yelling and rolling around on the clothing-strewn floor. The siblings have no father and an ailing mother and so are left to survive and grow up on their own. They’ve responded by creating a common fantasy world animated by a game of testing each others’ limits of patience and willingness to play along with the other.
Mother dies. Friend Gerard (a game Victor Gao) has a rich uncle who provides them with a new abode – which they promptly turn into a copy of their original close mess of a room. After a jealous Elizabeth manipulates Gerard and new friend Agathe (Caroline (Lina) DeFazio) out of their lives so as not to lose Paul to the temptations of the real world outside, the downer of an ending will not come as a surprise. The story leaves no chink for light to shine through upon these awful, fated people.

If you appreciate this rendering of Cocteau’s story it will be through the rabid performances of Kilgore and Scott. Under Gardner’s direction and aided by strong turns from Gao and DeFazio they create a lurid phantasmagoria of mental warping, dramatized before our eyes through a desperate physicality.
The production nicely evokes the 1920s. The siblings spout Shakespeare and trendy philosophy and fight over what to play on a wind-up phonograph. Elizabeth obsesses over the latest Hollywood gossip while Paul wallows in existential dread. Their creepy private world swept me up. Les Enfants Terribles is at the East Village Basement through October 4, 2026.
Blogcritics The critical lens on today's culture & entertainment