There’s a lot to parse just in the title of this uproarious and gut-punching new show. The Body of Mary actually refers to three different Marys, including Mary of Nazareth, and the three acts are really three one-act plays on a single theme: how the Catholic Church treats women’s bodies in the context of motherhood. Even the title’s parenthetical “of God” can be read as tongue-in-cheek.
Vessel
What writer-director Katie Cappiello has wrought are three stories on serious matters. They’re couched in comedy, colorfully staged, and intensely acted. The opening of “Act I: The Virgin” perfectly distills the show’s sensibility. A young teenage Mary of Nazareth (Annalisa D’Aguilar) is on the floor happily scrubbing laundry in one pail and vomiting in another.
Her mother Anne (Mary Jo Mecca) produces some weird gossip about an aging relation who has, seemingly miraculously, become pregnant. The foreshadowing is intentional: Soon Mary’s father Joachim (David Hull) arrives together with a sunny bolt of energy claiming to be the Archangel Gabriel. The announcement they bring explains Mary’s nausea, and despite the girl’s demurrals, it’s quickly clear that she will have no choice in the matter of the virgin birth assigned to her.
But is she really to be God’s vessel? There’s a clear suggestion of something more earthly and devious behind Mary’s situation. All this unfolds in spasms of hilarity that make the girl’s real predicament all the more touching and sad. The cast plays it all in grand comedic style.
Cardinal Sins
Set in the near future, “Act II: The Mother” presents Cardinal O’Malley (Hull again, here in prime (primate?) form), a thinly disguised anti-immigrant MAGA-type shyster. Just back in New York City after electing a new Pope – a “visionary” who will “get us back on track” – this fast-talking Millennial is a sharp-tongued political player – on and off the phone, shooting Nerf hoops, and bossing around his devoted but tough assistant Sister Genoveva (Mecca again, also prime).

This act’s Mary is the devout Mother Mary Joseph (a wonderful Tracy Sallows). The show’s moral center, she heads a convent that runs shelters for abandoned and immigrant children and women in need. O’Malley stuns her with a scheme he has concocted with his political cronies and abetted by Sister Genoveva, who is revealed as a kind of religious Nurse Ratched.
The plan they present as “in honor of life” is so heinous it might make Margaret Atwood shiver. You could sense and even hear the collective cringe of horror in the audience, spittled with nervous laughter, as time sped up and the plot glided toward realization.
Bag Baby
In “Act III: The Dumpster” a young Mary in Texas (a stellar Gracie Conn) finds a newborn abandoned in the middle of the night in the trash behind the Dairy Queen where she works. On the phone the whole time with her friend Nevaeh (D’Aguilar in a brilliant offstage performance) Mary tries to figure out what to do. The meat of the drama lies less in the finding of the baby than in Mary’s viscerally obvious bonding with it and, even more, in her speculations about the mother and what might have led whoever she was to leave her well-fed offspring in a dumpster.

The friends decide to anonymously leave the infant with a nearby Catholic charity. But things don’t go as planned, and two mute statues of Jesus and Mary stationed outside provide no succor. These figures are the perfect image of closure for the triptych, useless images with no connection in the real world. Strike three?
There’s more to The Body of Mary than a dastardly vision of the Catholic Church – an easy punching bag because of its long checkered history and famous/infamous policies. Cappiello satirizes cultural trends that today go well beyond Catholic dogma, and does so with a crossbow of stinging humor. Don’t miss this Gooddottirs Productions world premiere. See it at The Gym at Judson in Greenwich Village through October 8, 2026.
Blogcritics The critical lens on today's culture & entertainment